Ziaul Ahsan’s defence witness grilled over conflicting IDs, disputed evidence
Prosecutors have challenged the credibility of identity documents and other evidence submitted by the sole defence witness for former army general Ziaul Ahsan, accused of involvement in more than 100 enforced disappearances and killings during Awami League rule.
During cross-examination at International Crimes Tribunal-1 on Sunday, November 22, lawyer Taslima Jahan Popy acknowledged that she was unfamiliar with the contents of several documents, reports and videos she had submitted in Ziaul's defence.
The prosecution also questioned discrepancies in her national identity card, date of birth and Dhaka Bar Association membership records.
Popy denied allegations that she and another lawyer had colluded to fabricate documents to mislead the tribunal.
The tribunal, headed by Justice Md Golam Mortuza Mozumder, concluded witness testimony and scheduled closing arguments for November 24.
Ziaul, a retired major general and the sole accused in the case, attended the proceedings virtually for security reasons.
Questions over documents and their sources
Popy, who previously represented Ziaul in lower courts, told the tribunal that documents and video evidence had reached her through various channels.
She said some materials were supplied by Advocate Nazneen Nahar, while others arrived through sources she could not fully identify.
Asked when and how individual documents had been obtained, she said she could not recall all the details.
Prosecutor Mizanul Islam questioned her about military operations, the roles of officers, newspaper reports and video footage included among the defence exhibits.
Popy acknowledged having no direct personal knowledge of several matters addressed in the evidence.
She also said she was unfamiliar with the contents of certain reports and documents submitted to the tribunal.
The prosecution questioned the reliability of the materials, their sources and the methods used to collect them.
Questions were also raised about Google Maps evidence. Popy said she did not know when the mapping service had last been updated or whether updates were made regularly.
Prosecutors Gazi MH Tamim, Shaikh Mahdi and Tasmirul Islam were among those assisting Mizanul during the cross-examination.
Identity discrepancies draw scrutiny
The prosecution separately challenged information contained in Popy's national identity card and other personal records.
Questions centred on inconsistencies involving her date of birth, identification details and information appearing in documents issued by the Dhaka Bar Association.
Popy responded to the discrepancies, saying some details in the records concerned members of her family.
Prosecutors then suggested that inaccurate identification records and other documents had been submitted deliberately to mislead the tribunal.
She rejected the allegation.
Popy also denied that she and Nazneen had worked together to prepare misleading documents for Ziaul's defence.
The prosecution's allegations were contested during cross-examination, and the tribunal made no finding on whether the documents had been fabricated.
Ziaul faces crimes against humanity charges arising from allegations of enforced disappearances and killings during the Awami League government's tenure.
With testimony from both sides concluded, the tribunal will begin hearing closing arguments on November 24.
—