‘She will not go back’: Michael Kugelman on Hasina’s promised return
Sheikh Hasina is unlikely to return to Bangladesh despite her repeated promises, and the political unrest involving her supporters could serve her interests by putting pressure on the BNP-led government, according to American South Asia analyst Michael Kugelman.
“My view is that she actually will not go back to Bangladesh,” Kugelman told Daily Waadaa in an interview.
He suggested that the violence and instability could benefit the former prime minister, who has been living in New Delhi since her ouster in the August 2024 uprising.
“I hate to put it this way, but I think that all this unrest playing out in Bangladesh now will serve Hasina's interest, because it could put a lot more pressure on the government in power in Dhaka,” he said.
“She doesn't want this government to succeed, I would think.”
Hasina has pledged to return in December. Her announcement comes amid renewed violence involving Awami League supporters, who have recently burned at least 50 offices, even as the party calls for political reconciliation and a return to mainstream politics.
Kugelman said the government faced a difficult challenge in responding to the unrest without further escalating tensions.
He questioned whether meaningful reconciliation was possible while the Awami League continued to avoid responsibility for the crackdown on protesters during the 2024 uprising, which left up to 1,400 people dead, according to UN estimates.
“You can't have a true political reconciliation in Bangladesh unless the Awami League is involved,” he said.
“But the Awami League, based on its statements and its actions, has not indicated that it would be truly committed to reconciliation, because it all starts with acknowledging wrongs.”
Kugelman credited the government of Prime Minister Tarique Rahman with showing restraint during its initial months in office.
“I think that this government genuinely wants to be able to bury the hatchet and try to make things work politically with all players,” he said.
He noted that the administration “did not engage in the retributive politics that have come to define Bangladesh politics for many decades.”
But he warned that a sweeping crackdown on Awami League supporters could deepen the confrontation.
Such action “could make her supporters even angrier and it could produce even more volatility, even more violence,” he said.
Instead, Kugelman suggested discreet engagement with Awami League figures other than Hasina, whom the government regards “as a fugitive who should be extradited back to Bangladesh.”
‘A fool’s errand’
Kugelman also questioned Hasina's recent attempt to obtain a Bangladeshi passport, describing it as a move that appeared destined to fail.
During the interview, Waadaa pointed out that a document authorising a British law firm to apply for a passport on Hasina's behalf carried her signature in English, although she had previously signed documents in Bangla.
Kugelman declined to speculate about the signature but questioned the purpose of the application.
“She had to know that requesting a passport would not work, that the government would say no, because it views her as a fugitive,” he said.
“And she must have known that once the government said no, her supporters would react angrily.”
“To me, it seems like a fool's errand. There's no way the government's going to give her a passport.”
He said Hasina would face serious personal risks if she returned.
The former prime minister has been sentenced to death in absentia by Bangladesh's International Crimes Tribunal.
If she returned, Kugelman said, “she could be not only arrested... but even executed.”
Nevertheless, he cautioned against assuming that her political career was over.
“In South Asia, political dynasties, family dynasties are very strong. I think that she still has a political future,” he said.
He suggested that imprisonment could strengthen Hasina's political appeal among her supporters.
“If she were to end up in jail, I think that that victimization narrative could be very powerful and could stir up her base.”
Kugelman pointed to the BNP's return to power as evidence of how quickly Bangladesh's political circumstances can change.
“Who would have predicted even a few years ago that the BNP would be leading the government in Bangladesh? So things can change quickly.”
He also warned of further instability.
“Bangladesh is going to be one of the most volatile countries in South Asia next year,” he said, citing economic difficulties, energy pressures and what he called “the Hasina factor.”
Despite those concerns, Kugelman described the February election as “the first free and fair election in Bangladesh in a number of years.”
“I'm a friend of Bangladesh. I really would like to see the country stable, no matter who is in power,” he said.
‘Held hostage by Hasina’
On Bangladesh's relations with India, Kugelman said New Delhi had indicated its willingness to work with Tarique's government.
But Hasina's continued presence in India had complicated Dhaka's response, making closer engagement politically sensitive.
“When it comes to the India-Bangladesh relationship, the harder choices are going to have to be made on the Bangladesh side than on the India side,” he said.
Waadaa asked Kugelman about former US ambassador Dan Mozena's assessment, made in an earlier interview with the newspaper, that Hasina should not be allowed to hijack Bangladesh's India policy.
Kugelman broadly agreed.
“I think to an extent I agree with Ambassador Mozena, if I understand his point correctly, that the Bangladesh-India relationship has been held hostage by Hasina,” he said.
But he argued that responsibility did not rest with Hasina alone.
“Both Hasina and the Indian government are critical factors here,” he said.
India, he suggested, could have placed restrictions on her political activities while allowing her to remain in the country.
“You could stay in India, as long as you don't speak publicly,” he said, describing a condition New Delhi could have imposed.
Asked whether India should move beyond its relationship with Hasina and her family, including her son Sajeeb Wazed Joy and daughter Saima Wazed Putul, and engage with Bangladesh on broader terms, Kugelman pointed to longstanding grievances over Indian influence.
“There's been these strong perceptions for many years in Bangladesh that India meddles in Bangladesh and that it tries to shape domestic developments in ways that are unhealthy, if not wholly inappropriate,” he said.
He noted that the BNP wanted constructive relations with India, provided the relationship was based on equality.
The party, he said, sought good ties “so long as it happens on equal terms, meaning that it's not treated as a junior partner.”
The discussion also turned to India's criticism of Bangladesh over the treatment of Hindus.
Waadaa asked Kugelman whether New Delhi's concerns should be considered alongside the treatment of Muslims in India.
He acknowledged that the issue had become a source of friction.
“In Bangladesh the view would be: no, this is an exaggerated allegation, and also look at what happens to the Indian Muslims,” he said.
Kugelman suggested that India could reduce tensions by changing how it raised the issue.
He proposed “a very simple change, for New Delhi to scale back those allegations, or at least to not take them up publicly.”
The analyst in the ‘deep state’ crosshairs
Kugelman is a resident senior fellow for South Asia at the Atlantic Council in Washington, which he joined in late 2025.
He writes the weekly South Asia Brief for Foreign Policy magazine and previously spent nearly two decades at the Wilson Center, where he led its South Asia work and became founding director of the South Asia Institute in 2022.
His commentary on Bangladesh is widely followed and frequently attracts criticism online.
Following Waadaa's interview with former ambassador Mozena, some readers accused the American “deep state” of supporting the July 2024 uprising and attempting to prevent Hasina's political return.
Asked whether he was part of the US deep state, Kugelman dismissed the allegation.
“Naturally there's going to be that type of silly response. But no, I work for a private think tank. I have no connection to the US government,” he said.
He also questioned the suggestion that Bangladesh occupied a central place in Washington's current foreign policy calculations.
“Given that the world is literally on fire... Bangladesh is not high on the radar right now.”
Kugelman rejected claims that the United States had orchestrated or supported the 2024 uprising.
He said such allegations were also prevalent in India, including among senior figures.
“I also reject this notion that the U.S. deep state was involved in the 2024 uprising,” he said.
He compared Bangladesh's uprising with mass protest movements in Sri Lanka and Nepal, arguing that such political upheavals did not require foreign sponsorship.
“Mass movements can and typically are organic, they're grassroots,” he said.
“They don't need any type of external support or sponsorship to build.”
--